9.20.2006

Racial Politics and America's Next Top Model

Happy ANTM day, y'all. I'm all Ti-Voed up and ready to go. Girl's gotta have her share of skinny bitches competing for "fairest of them all" while she's reading about class struggle and feminism in WWII England.

I found this article (from Slate) about racial politics in ANTM interesting. The show is lauded for its color-blindness and multiculturalism. This season, we seem to be starting out with 8 white models (two of whom are identical twins), 4 African-American (or African) models, and one East Indian. Could it be that sponsor Cover Girl is trying to appeal to a wider audience? Could it be that Tyra is trying to parlay her success as one of the first African-American supermodels, and giving opportunities to girls of all races? (Past winners: 3 white, 2 black, 1 biracial.) Any way you slice it, the article has some interesting points:

"I don't want another black bitch," said Tyra to potential contestant Eva Pigford, confronting what had long remained subtext on reality TV. Eva, who was sometimes referred to as "Eva the Diva," experienced a significant attitude adjustment while under Tyra's tutelage and went on to win. But as Eva's star rose, Tyra's patience with her dark-skinned contestants began to wane. Tyra criticized Cycle 3 runner-up Yaya's "Afro-centric" head wraps, and in Cycle 4, she threw a spectacular hissy fit at Tiffany, a black mother from Miami. At the end of each episode of ANTM, one would-be model is sent home. When Tiffany, who sported tattoos and got into a bar fight on-camera, shrugged at the news of her elimination, Tyra exploded.

and:
Although Tyra had several problems with [last season's winner] Danielle—at one point bullying her to close the Lauren Hutton-esque gap in her smile—she was particularly unhappy about Danielle's "country" accent. Danielle does speak the way one might expect a young black woman from Arkansas to speak, but the lilting, syrupy sound of her voice is a huge part of her charm. All the judges—except Tyra—acknowledged this. While no one found it problematic that Jade (the "biracial butterfly"—her words—from New York City) peppered her speech with made-up words like "analystic," "dwelve," and "releasement," Tyra seemed unable to bear the fact that Danielle (who, incidentally, properly used the word cantankerous to describe herself when she gets pissy) had regional inflection in her voice. Even more to the point, Nnenna, the recently booted stunner from Nigeria, also spoke with a thick accent, which Tyra and the rest of the judges found fetching. Evidently, an African accent is fine, but not an African-American one. At last week's judging, Tyra told Danielle the judges "didn't trust her when she opened her mouth." But the truth is that the other judges loved Danielle, especially when she spoke, because she was articulate, modest, and hugely charismatic.

No comments: